Heat pumps are increasingly common across the United States for heating and cooling. Understanding supplemental heat, often called auxiliary or backup heat, helps homeowners maintain comfort and efficiency during cold spells. This article explains how supplemental heat operates, when it engages, options for supplemental systems, cost and efficiency considerations, and best practices for optimizing performance.
| Aspect | Primary Heat Pump | Supplemental Heat |
|---|---|---|
| Typical Function | Extracts heat from outdoor air or ground | Provides additional heat when heat pump capacity drops |
| Common Types | Air-source, ground-source | Electric resistance, gas furnace, dual-fuel |
| Efficiency | High COP/SEER when moderate temperatures | Lower efficiency (electric resistance) or variable (gas) |
| Cost Impact | Lower operational cost normally | Can increase energy bills during cold weather |
Content Navigation
- What Is Supplemental Heat For Heat Pumps?
- Why Heat Pumps Need Supplemental Heat
- Types Of Supplemental Heat
- How Supplemental Heat Is Controlled
- Energy Efficiency And Cost Considerations
- When And Why To Use Dual-Fuel Systems
- Installation And Sizing Considerations
- Maintenance And Performance Tips
- How To Reduce Reliance On Supplemental Heat
- Typical Questions Homeowners Ask
- Case Studies And Practical Examples
- Key Takeaways For Homeowners
- Resources And Further Reading
What Is Supplemental Heat For Heat Pumps?
Supplemental heat refers to an auxiliary heating source that activates when the heat pump alone cannot meet the thermostat demand or when outdoor temperatures reduce heat pump efficiency. Many systems call this auxiliary (aux) heat or backup heat. Its role is to maintain indoor setpoint and avoid long runtime or compressor strain.
Why Heat Pumps Need Supplemental Heat
Heat pumps transfer heat rather than generate it, and their ability to extract heat from the air declines as outdoor temperatures fall. Supplemental heat becomes necessary when the heat pump’s heating capacity drops below the home’s heat loss at low temperatures or when rapid temperature recovery is required.
Common Triggers For Supplemental Heat
- Outdoor temperature below the heat pump’s balance point where capacity equals building losses.
- Defrost cycles on air-source heat pumps temporarily reduce output.
- Rapid thermostat increases or setpoint recovery after a setback (economy mode).
- Maintenance or malfunction reducing heat pump performance.
Types Of Supplemental Heat
Multiple supplemental heat options exist, each with advantages and trade-offs. Choice depends on climate, fuel availability, efficiency goals, and cost considerations.
Electric Resistance (Strip Heater)
Electric resistance heat is the most common supplemental option in packaged air-source heat pump systems and is often integrated. It is reliable and fast-acting but typically expensive to operate due to lower efficiency compared with heat pumps or gas furnaces.
Gas Furnace As Backup (Dual-Fuel Systems)
Dual-fuel systems combine a heat pump with a gas furnace. The control switches to the furnace when outdoor temperatures drop below a predetermined setpoint. This approach can be cost-effective in colder climates where gas is cheaper than electricity for high loads.
Hybrid Or Zoned Supplemental Systems
Zoned systems or ductless mini-split supplemental units can heat specific areas where the heat pump struggles. Ground-source heat pumps (geothermal) typically require less supplemental heat but can still use backup heaters in extreme conditions.
How Supplemental Heat Is Controlled
Controls determine when supplemental heat engages. Modern thermostats and control logic use temperature, time, and demand signals to activate supplemental sources efficiently.
Balance Point Control
The balance point is the ambient temperature where heat pump output equals the building’s heat losses. When outdoor temperature falls below the balance point, the system will call for supplemental heat to maintain comfort.
Auxiliary Heat Lockout And Outdoor Reset
Some systems include an auxiliary heat lockout to prevent the backup heat from running until the heat pump has been given a chance to meet demand. Outdoor reset controls modulate backup start points and furnace staging to improve efficiency.
Energy Efficiency And Cost Considerations
Choosing and managing supplemental heat affects operating costs. Understanding efficiency metrics and typical usage patterns helps homeowners minimize bills while maintaining comfort.
Comparing Efficiency Metrics
Heat pumps are rated by SEER (cooling) and HSPF or Heating COP (heating). Supplemental electric resistance heat has a coefficient of performance of 1.0, meaning each unit of electricity produces one unit of heat, making it less efficient than heat pumps that often exceed COP of 2–4 in mild conditions.
Cost Scenarios
| Scenario | Likely Cost Impact | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Mild Winter | Low | Heat pump handles most load; minimal supplemental use |
| Cold Snap, Electric Strip Heat | High | Rapidly increases electric bills due to low efficiency |
| Cold Snap, Dual-Fuel | Moderate | Gas furnace can reduce electric consumption but adds gas cost |
When And Why To Use Dual-Fuel Systems
Dual-fuel systems switch from electric heat pump operation to a fossil-fuel furnace at a control temperature to optimize cost and performance. They are particularly effective in regions with long, cold winters and where natural gas prices are favorable relative to electricity.
Benefits Of Dual-Fuel
- Operational cost savings during deep cold when heat pump COP is low.
- Reduced reliance on electric resistance heat means less extreme electric demand spikes.
- More predictable performance in severe cold.
Trade-Offs
Dual-fuel systems require proper control integration, higher upfront cost, and ongoing maintenance for two heat sources. Fuel price volatility affects economic benefits.
Installation And Sizing Considerations
Proper design and sizing of both the heat pump and supplemental system are critical to performance. Oversized supplemental heaters waste energy; undersized units create discomfort during extreme conditions.
Sizing The Heat Pump And Backup
A qualified HVAC contractor should perform a manual J heat load calculation to determine the building’s heat loss. The heat pump should be sized to cover a large portion of the load in the expected temperature range, and the supplemental system should be sized to cover remaining load during extreme cold.
Controls And Integration
Thermostat compatibility and system controls must be verified. Smart thermostats with heat pump and auxiliary heat settings improve efficiency by preventing unnecessary auxiliary activation and supporting setback recovery strategies.
Maintenance And Performance Tips
Regular maintenance helps minimize unnecessary supplemental heat use and ensures systems run efficiently year-round.
- Keep outdoor units clear of snow and debris to preserve airflow and capacity.
- Change filters regularly to maintain indoor airflow and heat exchange performance.
- Schedule annual professional tune-ups for both heat pump and any supplemental furnace.
- Use programmable or smart thermostats to avoid manual overuse of backup heat.
How To Reduce Reliance On Supplemental Heat
Reducing supplemental heat usage lowers energy bills and improves comfort. Combining system optimization with home efficiency upgrades yields the best results.
Improve Building Envelope
Insulation upgrades, air-sealing, and high-performance windows reduce heat loss, allowing the heat pump to meet demand at lower outdoor temperatures.
Optimize Thermostat Strategy
Using gradual setpoint changes, avoiding deep setbacks, and using recovery strategies can prevent frequent auxiliary heat engagement. Smart thermostats can learn and adapt to reduce unnecessary backup use.
Consider High-Performance Heat Pumps
Cold-climate heat pumps can maintain higher COPs at lower temperatures, reducing the need for supplemental heat. Upgrading to a cold-climate model may provide long-term energy savings.
Typical Questions Homeowners Ask
Why Is Auxiliary Heat Running Even When It’s Not That Cold?
Auxiliary heat can run during compressor startup, defrost cycles, or if the thermostat senses rapid demand or a fault. Confirm thermostat settings and check for system faults before assuming a major issue.
Is Supplemental Heat Bad For The Heat Pump?
Supplemental heat itself does not harm the heat pump if controls are correct. Overuse, however, indicates inefficiency or a system mismatch that may increase wear and energy costs.
How Much Will Supplemental Heat Add To My Bill?
Cost depends on supplemental type, climate, and usage. Electric resistance heat is generally the most expensive, potentially doubling electric usage during heavy use. Dual-fuel systems typically add gas cost but can reduce electric bills during cold periods.
Case Studies And Practical Examples
Example 1: A New England home with a ducted air-source heat pump and electric strip heat saw high winter electric bills until a dual-fuel system with a gas furnace and outdoor temperature lockout was installed. The household saw lower overall energy costs and improved comfort during prolonged cold spells.
Example 2: A Pacific Northwest household upgraded to a cold-climate mini-split. Supplemental heat use dropped markedly, and the electric utility peak demand decreased, thanks to improved low-temperature COP and zoning controls.
Key Takeaways For Homeowners
Understand The Role Of Supplemental Heat: It is a necessary safety and comfort feature in many heat pump systems during cold conditions. Choose Wisely: Compare electric resistance, dual-fuel, and advanced heat pump options based on local fuel costs and climate. Optimize Controls And Building Efficiency To reduce reliance on supplemental heat and lower operating costs.
Tips for Getting the Best HVAC Prices
- Prioritize Quality Over Cost
The most critical factor in any HVAC project is the quality of the installation. Don’t compromise on contractor expertise just to save money. - Check for Rebates
Always research current rebates and incentives — they can significantly reduce your overall cost. - Compare Multiple Quotes
Request at least three estimates before making your choice. You can click here to get three free quotes from local professionals. These quotes include available rebates and tax credits and automatically exclude unqualified contractors. - Negotiate Smartly
Once you've chosen a contractor, use the proven strategies from our guide — How Homeowners Can Negotiate with HVAC Dealers — to get the best possible final price.