Quick Overview: Choosing the right heater for a spa depends on spa size, fuel type, portability, and temperature control. Below is a comparison table of five relevant products covering spa inline heaters, pool/spa gas heaters, and heated foot spas for personal use.
| Product | Type | Key Feature |
|---|---|---|
| VODCACA 73791 Hot Tub Heater | Replacement Electric Spa Heater | Titanium steel element, broad compatibility |
| Hayward W3H150FDN Universal H-Series | Natural Gas Pool & Spa Heater | 150,000 BTU, cupro-nickel heat exchanger |
| OOAMBB Collapsible Foot Spa | Portable Foot Spa Heater | Touch screen, 95–118°F temp range |
| Ranjova Collapsible Foot Spa | Foot Bath With Rotary Massage | 24 motorized shiatsu balls, auto temp hold |
| HOSPAN FS02A Collapsible Foot Spa | Foot Spa With Remote | Remote control, 3 massage modes, temp control |
Content Navigation
VODCACA 73791 Hot Tub Heater
Type: Inline Replacement Heater For Hot Tubs And Spas.
This heater is marketed as a direct replacement for common spa heater models (C3160-2S, C3160-2, C3564-2, 73791, 73039, 6758). It is offered in 120V 1kW and 240V 4kW variants, making it suitable for different hot tub controller configurations.
Notable Features: The unit uses titanium steel construction for the heating element, which enhances corrosion resistance. It includes an overheat protection device that stops heating at dangerous temperatures. The manufacturer emphasizes compatibility with many spa systems from Spring/Watkins/Tiger River/Limelight.
Use Cases: Designed primarily for in-line hot tub heater replacement, it is also suitable for small spas and inflatable pools that accept similar electrical heaters. Installation requires correct voltage selection and alignment with existing thermostat/flow switch assemblies.
Call 888-896-7031 for Free Local HVAC Quotes – Compare and Save Today!
Hayward Universal H-Series 150
Type: Natural Gas Pool And Spa Heater For In-Ground Pools.
This Hayward H-Series heater delivers 150,000 BTU output for larger pools and spas requiring significant heat-up capability. The unit includes a cupro-nickel heat exchanger
Notable Features: The heater claims an industry-leading hydraulic design to reduce circulation pump run time, which can reduce overall operational energy. The robust construction targets long-term reliability in residential in-ground installations.
Use Cases: Best suited for medium to large in-ground pools with connected spa systems or standalone spas that use natural gas. Professional installation is required for gas connection, venting, and water plumbing integration.
OOAMBB Collapsible Foot Spa With Heat
Call 888-896-7031 for Free Local HVAC Quotes – Compare and Save Today!
Type: Portable Electric Foot Bath With Temperature Control.
The OOAMBB foot spa is designed for at-home foot care with a large touch screen controlling temperature, bubble function, and timer. Temperature control spans 95°F to 118°F and an intelligent control maintains the set point.
Notable Features: Functions include oxygen bubbles, vibration, timer from 10–60 minutes, and XL touch controls. The product notes UL certification documentation availability, indicating attention to safety standards for consumer electrical devices.
Use Cases: Suited for personal foot soaking, pedicure prep, and circulation-promoting therapy for daily use. The collapsible design aids storage and portability for small living spaces.
Ranjova Collapsible Foot Spa Rotary Massage
Type: Foot Bath With Motorized Shiatsu Balls And Temperature Hold.
The Ranjova unit features 24 motorized shiatsu massage balls grouped into a 3D Tai Chi massage layout with three adjustable massage modes: continuous, intermittent, and intelligent. Temperature control is precise and displayed on a touch screen, holding settings between 95°F and 118°F.
Notable Features: The massage base and balls are detachable for cleaning. The automatic rotary massage targets acupuncture points on the soles for pressure relief and circulation support. A large touch screen simplifies operation.
Use Cases: Mobile personal spa use, therapeutic foot relaxation after standing or exercise, and pedicure support. The removable parts aid hygiene management.
HOSPAN Collapsible Foot Spa FS02A
Type: Foot Soak Tub With Remote And Multi-Mode Massage.
The HOSPAN FS02A is equipped with six groups of 3D Tai Chi massage balls, offering three massage frequency modes and continuous oxygen bubble delivery. Temperature ranges from 95°F to 118°F and the unit maintains set temperature without adding hot water.
Notable Features: Magnetic remote control for hands-free adjustments, detachable massage components, and intelligent temperature control. The remote requires line-of-sight to the display for operation within about 1 meter.
Use Cases: Designed for users who prefer remote adjustments, those who seek varied massage profiles, and people wanting consistent foot soak temperatures during therapy sessions.
Buying Guide: Choosing The Right Spa Heater
Selecting a spa heater requires matching the heater type to the spa’s scale, fuel availability, and desired control features. Below are key considerations to evaluate before purchase.
1. Heater Type And Fuel Source
- Electric Inline Replacement Heaters: Designed for hot tubs and portable spas with existing plumbing and controllers. Suitable for various small to medium residential tubs.
- Gas Heaters (Natural Gas/Propane): Provide high output for in-ground pools and large spa systems. Require gas hookup, venting, and professional installation.
- Portable Foot Spa Heaters: Low-capacity electric heaters built into foot baths. Ideal for personal therapy and pedicure needs, not for heating full-size hot tubs.
2. Compatibility And Sizing
- Replacement Elements: Verify model numbers and physical dimensions. Many spa controls expect specific heater assemblies and electrical ratings.
- BTU Or kW Output: For pools/spas, choose a heater with sufficient BTU (gas) or kW (electric) to maintain target temperature given spa volume and local heat loss factors.
- Flow Requirements: Some heaters require minimum pump flow or flow switches; ensure plumbing and circulation meet these needs.
3. Materials And Durability
- Heat Exchanger Materials: Cupro-nickel and titanium alloys resist corrosion in variable water chemistry better than standard copper in many cases.
- Enclosure And Seals: Outdoor or wet-area installations need weather-resistant enclosures and proper electrical protections.
4. Temperature Control And Safety
- Precision Controls: Digital thermostats and displays make it easier to set and maintain desired temperatures.
- Safety Features: Look for overheat protection, thermal cutouts, and UL/ETL certification for electrical safety on consumer devices.
- Automatic Temperature Hold: Keeps water at setpoint without constant manual reheating—useful for foot spas and tubs with variable usage.
5. Installation And Maintenance
- Professional Installation: Required for gas heaters and recommended for high-voltage electric replacements to ensure safe wiring and gas venting.
- Service Access: Choose units with accessible elements for inspection and replacement to minimize downtime.
- Cleaning And Removable Parts: For foot spas, removable massage plates and balls simplify cleaning and reduce hygiene risks.
6. Energy Efficiency And Operating Cost
- Hydraulic And Heat Exchanger Design: Efficient designs reduce pump runtime and fuel usage over time.
- Insulation And Covers: Use spa covers, insulated plumbing, and timers to reduce heat loss and operational cost regardless of heater type.
7. User Experience Features
- Controls: Touch screens, remote controls, and programmable timers increase convenience.
- Massage Options: For foot spas, multiple massage modes, rollers, and bubble functions add therapeutic variability.
- Portability: Collapsible designs are beneficial for small homes and storage.
8. Safety And Certification
- Certifications: For portable electric devices, UL/ETL marks and compliance statements indicate adherence to safety standards.
- Temperature Limits: Ensure devices have thermostat limits and automatic shutoffs to prevent scalding and overheating.
Comparison Perspectives
Performance vs. Scale: Gas heaters like the Hayward model provide high BTU output appropriate for large pools and connected spas, while inline electric elements such as the VODCACA replacement serve hot tubs where voltage and control compatibility matter.
Portability vs. Capacity: Foot spa heaters (OOAMBB, Ranjova, HOSPAN) offer portability and targeted heat for feet but are not intended for full-size spa heating. They excel in personal therapy, ease of storage, and quick heat-up times.
Durability vs. Cost To Maintain: Materials such as cupro-nickel and titanium steel lengthen component life in corrosive water conditions, potentially reducing replacement frequency. This consideration may increase upfront cost but reduce long-term maintenance.
Ease Of Use vs. Professional Requirements: Consumer foot spas are plug-and-play with user-friendly controls. In contrast, gas heaters and some high-voltage electric replacements require expert installation, permits, or plumbing modifications.
Tips for Getting the Best HVAC Prices
- Prioritize Quality Over Cost
The most critical factor in any HVAC project is the quality of the installation. Don’t compromise on contractor expertise just to save money. - Check for Rebates
Always research current rebates and incentives — they can significantly reduce your overall cost. - Compare Multiple Quotes
Request at least three estimates before making your choice. You can click here to get three free quotes from local professionals. These quotes include available rebates and tax credits and automatically exclude unqualified contractors. - Negotiate Smartly
Once you've chosen a contractor, use the proven strategies from our guide — How Homeowners Can Negotiate with HVAC Dealers — to get the best possible final price.