Choosing The Right Hot Tub Heater depends on tub size, power availability, and whether you want off-grid or electric heating. Below is a quick comparison of the five selected products that match common hot tub heating needs.
| Product | Type | Primary Use |
|---|---|---|
| ALEKO External Wood-Burning Hot Tub Heater | Wood-Burning External Heater | Off-grid Backyard Hot Tubs |
| 1800W Immersion Water Heater (BSUOWEK) | Electric Immersion Heater | Small Hot Tubs, Inflatable Pools, Buckets |
| DERNORD Cartridge Heater 12V 100W | Cartridge/Submersible Heating Element | Small DIY Hot Rods, Custom Systems |
| Camco Water Heater Dip Tube (11163) | Replacement Dip Tube | Preserving Hot Water In Tank Heaters |
| Rheem AP12933 Water Heater Dip Tube | Replacement Dip Tube | Preserving Hot Water In Tank Heaters |
Content Navigation
External Wood-Burning Hot Tub Heater | ALEKO
Type: External Wood-Burning Hot Tub Heater. Best For: Off-grid or rustic backyard tubs where electricity is limited or not desired.
This stainless steel external heater connects to a hot tub using the included high temperature silicone pipes and clamps. It functions without pumps or wiring and is designed to be resistant to rust and corrosion. The heater is intended to produce heat comparable to a 10–15 kW electronic heater when paired properly with a hot tub system.
Notable features include off-grid operation, included connecting pipes and clamps, and a chimney with an anti-scald cover. Installation requires matching pipe sizes and safe placement of the wood stove element. Performance depends on tub volume, insulation, and fire management practices.
1800W Immersion Water Heater For Pool | BSUOWEK
Call 888-896-7031 for Free Local HVAC Quotes – Compare and Save Today!
Type: Electric Submersible Immersion Heater. Best For: Small hot tubs, inflatable pools, stock tanks, and portable use.
This model uses a 1800W stainless steel heating rod to accelerate temperature rise. The construction specifies 304 stainless steel for corrosion resistance and higher thermal conductivity. Safety features highlighted include ETL-certified plugs and waterproof wiring to minimize electrical risk when used according to manufacturer guidelines.
Intended for temporary or supplemental heating, immersion heaters are suited to smaller volumes of water and require careful monitoring to avoid dry-run or improper placement. Continuous use specifications and run-time limits are provided by the manufacturer; users should follow local electrical codes for outdoor use.
DERNORD Cartridge Heater 12V 100W Electric Hot Rod
Type: Cartridge / Rod Heater. Best For: Small DIY hot tub heater projects, custom immersion assemblies, or low-volume heating tasks.
This cartridge heater is a compact element designed for 12V systems at 100W output with an 8mm tube diameter and 100mm length. It is suitable for small-scale heating tasks or integration into bespoke systems where low-voltage heating is required.
Call 888-896-7031 for Free Local HVAC Quotes – Compare and Save Today!
Because of its limited wattage, this element is suitable only for small volumes or as a supplemental heater. Proper thermal housing, waterproofing, and appropriate power supply are essential when adapting cartridge heaters for water heating. Users should ensure safe electrical isolation and compatible control circuitry.
Camco Water Heater Dip Tube | 50.5-Inch (11163)
Type: Replacement Dip Tube For Tank Water Heaters. Best For: Preserving hot water availability in storage tank heaters used to supply tubs or showers.
While not a heater itself, a functioning dip tube helps direct cold inlet water to the bottom of a storage tank heater, preserving hot water at the top and improving apparent hot water capacity. This Camco dip tube is threaded for standard inlet connections and includes an anti-siphon hole to prevent damaging siphon action.
For setups that rely on a traditional tank water heater to supply hot tub fill water, maintaining an effective dip tube improves recovery and efficiency. This product is a direct replacement part and addresses hot water distribution rather than heat generation.
Rheem AP12933 Water Heater Dip Tube | 53-Inch
Type: Replacement Dip Tube For Water Heaters. Best For: Tank heaters used in tandem with tubs, ensuring better hot water preservation.
This Rheem dip tube provides similar function to other replacement dip tubes: directing cold inlet water to the tank bottom to maximize available hot water and recovery performance. It includes a 3/4″ NPT nipple and is specified at 1/2″ diameter by 53″ length for compatibility with many common tanks.
Improving the performance of a storage water heater can influence how quickly a hot tub refill reaches usable temperature, particularly when a conventional tank is used for initial heating or for topping off a tub during use.
Buying Guide: How To Choose A Hot Tub Heater
Selecting a heater requires matching heating capacity, energy source, safety needs, and installation constraints to your hot tub specifics.
Tips for Getting the Best HVAC Prices
- Prioritize Quality Over Cost
The most critical factor in any HVAC project is the quality of the installation. Don’t compromise on contractor expertise just to save money. - Check for Rebates
Always research current rebates and incentives — they can significantly reduce your overall cost. - Compare Multiple Quotes
Request at least three estimates before making your choice. You can click here to get three free quotes from local professionals. These quotes include available rebates and tax credits and automatically exclude unqualified contractors. - Negotiate Smartly
Once you've chosen a contractor, use the proven strategies from our guide — How Homeowners Can Negotiate with HVAC Dealers — to get the best possible final price.
Heating Type And Energy Source
- Electric Immersion Heaters: Simple and portable. Best for small tubs and short-term use. Require safe outdoor-rated electrical connections and are typically lower wattage than installed electric heaters.
- External Wood-Burning Heaters: Off-grid option with no electrical needs. Better for rustic setups and larger temperature increases if sized and managed correctly. They require space, ventilation, and fire safety practices.
- Cartridge/Element Heaters: For custom or DIY systems. Low-voltage elements need proper enclosures and controls. Suitable for small volumes or integrated heater assemblies.
- Tank Water Heater Integration: Using existing water heaters can be economical for refills or topping off, but requires ensuring dip tubes and plumbing are optimized for hot water delivery.
Power And Heating Capacity
- Wattage Matters: Larger tubs require higher wattage or longer heating times. Compare heater wattage to tub volume (gallons) to estimate heat-up time.
- Voltage And Circuit Requirements: Verify household circuits, outdoor outlet ratings, GFCI protection, and whether a dedicated circuit is needed.
- Continuous Duty Rating: Check manufacturer specifications for recommended run time and duty cycles to avoid damage or safety hazards.
Safety And Certification
- Electrical Safety: Look for ETL/UL listings for outdoor electrical heaters. Use GFCI-protected circuits and outdoor-rated cords and plugs.
- Waterproofing & Grounding: Only use heaters designed for immersion in water. Cartridge heaters must be properly sealed and housed when used near water.
- Fire Safety: With wood-burning heaters, ensure clearances, chimney venting, and stable placement to avoid accidental fires and scalding.
Compatibility And Installation
- Plumbing Connections: For external stoves, verify pipe diameters and that included connectors match your tub inlets or outlets.
- Material Durability: Stainless steel heating surfaces resist corrosion in outdoor or chlorinated environments. Confirm grade (304 vs 316) based on water chemistry.
- Controls And Thermostats: Some heaters include or support thermostatic control; others rely on manual management. Consider how precise temperature control needs to be.
Operational Considerations
- Heat-Up Time Vs Efficiency: High-wattage heaters heat faster but may demand heavier electrical infrastructure. Wood heaters require fire management but can sustain large heat output over time.
- Maintenance: Regular cleaning, inspection of seals and wiring, and replacement of sacrificial parts (anodes, dip tubes) extend system life.
- Environmental And Practical Factors: Noise, smoke, fuel availability, and local regulations (open burning restrictions) affect suitability.
Comparison Perspectives
- Performance: For immediate, short-term heating in small tubs, an immersion heater is the most straightforward. For sustained heating of larger volumes, external wood or built-in electric systems are more effective.
- Cost And Infrastructure: Immersion heaters require minimal setup cost but higher electricity draw. Wood-burning units require fuel but can be cost-effective off-grid.
- Flexibility: Cartridge heaters and immersion rods offer modularity for DIY projects. External stoves are specialized and require more installation effort but enable off-grid operation.
Checklist Before Purchase
- Confirm tub volume (gallons) and desired temperature rise/time.
- Check available electrical supply (voltage, amps, GFCI protection).
- Assess space and ventilation for wood-burning heaters.
- Verify materials are compatible with your water chemistry (chlorine, minerals).
- Plan for safe installation, mounting, and regular maintenance access.