Overview: This guide compares top tube-style fireplace heaters and related heating components to help you choose the right unit for a hearth, garage, patio, or electric supplemental heating. Below is a quick summary of the selected products for side-by-side reference.
| Product | Brand | Primary Feature |
|---|---|---|
| Spitfire 6-Tube Fireplace Heater | Woodeze | 6 aluminized steel tubes, 2-speed blower, 45,000 BTU |
| SunStar Garage Tube Heater SIR45-15-L | Sunstar | 45,000 BTU LP tube heater, compact 110″ length, up to 84.5% efficiency |
| MENSI Propane Burner Replacement Kit | MENSI | Propane burner assembly for tube patio heaters, regulator and hose included |
| MCAMPAS Stainless Steel Pilot Tube | MCAMPAS | 24″ 1/4″ OD flex stainless pilot tube for gas appliances |
| Duraflame Freestanding Electric Stove Heater | Duraflame | Portable electric infrared stove, 3D flame effect, 1,000 sq. ft. coverage |
Content Navigation
Spitfire 6-Tube Fireplace Heater
The Spitfire Fireplace Heater uses six heavy-gauge aluminized steel tubes to extract heat from a wood fire and transfer it into the room. Its design is intended to increase convective heat transfer compared with an open firebox, improving overall heating efficiency without additional fuel consumption.
The unit includes a two-speed blower to control circulation between low and high settings. This provides flexibility for slower background warming or faster distribution when needed. The Spitfire is sized to fit smaller fireplaces while producing the manufacturer-stated 45,000 BTUs heat potential. For homeowners with compact hearths, the compact footprint is a notable characteristic.
SunStar Garage Tube Heater
The SunStar SIR45-15-L is a 45,000 BTU liquid propane tube heater commonly used in garages and commercial bays. With an overall length of 110 inches, the product is designed for easier installation and overhead mounting. The manufacturer reports efficiencies up to 84.5%, which is relevant when assessing fuel usage and heat delivery.
Call 888-896-7031 for Free Local HVAC Quotes – Compare and Save Today!
Installation guidance indicates mounting clearances and recommends heights as low as 8 feet above the floor for effective radiant and convective distribution. This model represents the tube-heater design tailored for workshops and open indoor spaces rather than enclosed wood hearths.
MENSI Propane Burner Kit
The MENSI 4 Bolts Propane Burner is a replacement burner and regulator assembly for patio tube heaters. It includes a regulator hose, QCC connector, and mounting holes for retrofit installation. The kit is rated for high output up to an indicated 60,000 BTU maximum heating element, making it suitable for commercial-style outdoor tube heaters.
This product is focused on replacement and DIY modification of propane-powered tube heaters. It provides the functional components needed to restore or upgrade the fuel delivery and burner on existing tube heater systems. Verify compatibility with your heater model, fittings, and local fuel codes before installation.
MCAMPAS Pilot Tube For Gas Appliances
The MCAMPAS 1/4″ Pilot Tube is a flexible stainless steel pilot line intended for gas appliances such as fireplaces, stoves, and water heaters. With a 24-inch length and 1/4″ OD, it serves as a reliable connection between pilot assemblies and gas valves. Material choice (stainless steel) reduces corrosion risk in gas lines.
Call 888-896-7031 for Free Local HVAC Quotes – Compare and Save Today!
Use cases include pilot line replacement or repositioning during appliance installation or repair. This kit is applicable when maintaining tube or burner-style heating systems that rely on a pilot supply for ignition and safety controls. Follow gas-safety practices when replacing pilot tubing.
Duraflame Freestanding Electric Stove Heater
The Duraflame Freestanding Electric Fireplace Stove is a portable electric heater that uses infrared elements and a 3D flame effect. It is designed to heat rooms up to 1,000 square feet and can be used as a supplemental heat source to reduce central heating demand. The stove includes side viewing windows and a realistic flame display.
Unlike combustion tube heaters, this electric unit does not require venting, pilot lines, or fuel connections. It offers portable supplemental heating and atmospheric ambiance. This style is relevant for buyers seeking a tube-like visual presence or supplemental warmth where gas or wood options are impractical.
Buying Guide: How To Choose A Tube Fireplace Heater
Selecting the right tube-style heater or related component depends on the intended application: in-fireplace heat exchangers, overhead garage tube heaters, outdoor patio burners, or electric supplemental stoves. Below are the key considerations to compare options objectively.
Heating Type And Intended Location
- Fireplace Tube Heater (Wood Hearth): Designed to sit inside a firebox, pull combustion heat across metal tubes, and use a blower to push warmed air into the room.
- Garage Or Space Tube Heater: Long, suspended tube heaters typically run on gas and deliver radiant heat across large, open spaces.
- Patio Tube Burner Kits: Propane burners and regulators attach to tall patio heaters for outdoor radiant heat.
- Electric Freestanding Heaters: Portable, vent-free, and best for supplemental indoor heat where fuel or venting is not available.
Heat Output And Coverage
- Compare BTU ratings or wattage to the size of the area you want to heat. Tube hearth inserts often list BTU estimates; for electric heaters use square-foot coverage.
- For open spaces, prefer higher BTU tube heaters or multiple heat sources. For enclosed rooms, a fireplace tube insert or electric stove may be more efficient.
Efficiency And Heat Transfer
- Material And Tube Design: Aluminized steel or other high-conductivity metals improve heat transfer from the firebox to room air.
- Blower Presence: A blower speeds convective distribution. Two-speed blowers let you balance noise and circulation.
- Radiant vs. Convective: Garage tube heaters emphasize radiant heat; fireplace tube inserts emphasize convective transfer via tubes and blowers.
Installation And Clearances
- Review clearance requirements for hearth inserts and overhead tube heaters. Many garage units specify a minimum mounting height and clearances from combustible materials.
- Consider existing chimney or hearth dimensions when selecting a fireplace insert. For gas and propane units, verify local codes and professional installation requirements.
Fuel Source And Safety
- Wood-Fired Inserts: Rely on solid fuel; ensure your chimney and hearth are safe and that the insert fits the firebox.
- Gas Or Propane Tube Heaters: Require proper regulators, connectors, and often professional installation for safe operation.
- Electric: Vent-free, plug-in operation reduces fuel handling but must match room wiring and circuit capacity.
- Always follow manufacturer safety instructions, local codes, and consider adding carbon monoxide detection when using combustion heaters indoors.
Maintenance And Durability
- Tube heaters exposed to combustion require periodic inspection for corrosion, tube integrity, and blower function.
- Propane burner kits and pilot tubing should be checked for leaks, proper fittings, and secure mounts.
- Electric units require less fuel maintenance but should be cleaned and inspected for wiring and element integrity over time.
Compatibility And Retrofit Concerns
- When replacing burners or pilot tubing, confirm sizes and connector types match your existing heater or appliance.
- Retrofit kits like burner assemblies and pilot tubes work for repairs but must be compatible with the unit’s valve specifications and mounting arrangements.
Noise, Controls, And Convenience
- Consider blower noise and available speed settings. Two-speed blowers provide a balance between quiet operation and rapid heat circulation.
- Remote controls, thermostats, and variable output enhance convenience for daily use.
Comparison Perspectives
- Performance vs. Footprint: Fireplace tube inserts like the Spitfire aim to increase output without expanding the physical hearth footprint.
- Installation Complexity vs. Coverage: Garage tube heaters deliver wide coverage but require overhead mounting and gas hookups; electric stoves provide simple plug-and-play installation for single-room heating.
- Repairability: Replacement burners and pilot tubing offer cost-effective maintenance for gas and propane tube systems compared with full unit replacement.
Use the guide above to match unit type, fuel source, and installation needs with your home or space. Confirm compatibility, safety requirements, and professional installation where applicable before purchase or retrofit work.
Tips for Getting the Best HVAC Prices
- Prioritize Quality Over Cost
The most critical factor in any HVAC project is the quality of the installation. Don’t compromise on contractor expertise just to save money. - Check for Rebates
Always research current rebates and incentives — they can significantly reduce your overall cost. - Compare Multiple Quotes
Request at least three estimates before making your choice. You can click here to get three free quotes from local professionals. These quotes include available rebates and tax credits and automatically exclude unqualified contractors. - Negotiate Smartly
Once you've chosen a contractor, use the proven strategies from our guide — How Homeowners Can Negotiate with HVAC Dealers — to get the best possible final price.