Choosing the best heater for pools depends on pool size, fuel source, climate, budget, and installation preferences. Below is a concise comparison of five heaters that represent common approaches: inverter heat pumps, gas heaters, electric plug-in heat pumps, and solar panels.
| Product | Type | Best For |
|---|---|---|
| AQUASTRONG Inverter Pool Heat Pump | Inverter Heat Pump | Large pools up to 9,000 gallons; remote control |
| Hayward Universal H-Series Natural Gas Heater | Natural Gas Heater | Rapid heating for in-ground pools and spas |
| VARMINPOOL 16000BTU Pool Heat Pump | Electric Inverter Heat Pump | Above-ground pools up to ~5,400 gallons; WiFi |
| ECO POOLTECH EU50 Electric Pool Heater | Plug-In Electric Heat Pump | Smaller pools up to 5,000 gallons; energy efficient |
| Goplus Solar Pool Heater | Solar Panel Heater | Supplemental heating; low operational cost |
Content Navigation
Aquastrong Inverter Swimming Pool Heat Pump
This inverter heat pump is rated at 35,000 BTU and designed for pools up to 9,000 gallons. It supports both heating (47–104°F) and cooling (47–83°F), providing year-round temperature control. The unit includes WiFi-capable app control and programmable timers for remote operation and energy tracking. The full DC variable frequency technology claims a 15.8 COP and adaptive frequency conversion to optimize energy use compared to traditional electric heating. Features emphasize rapid heating for large pools and an app-based control interface for scheduling and monitoring.
Suitability: Good for larger residential pools where efficient, continuous heating and remote management are priorities. Requires proper installation space and outdoor clearance for heat exchange. Performance depends on ambient conditions; inverter technology maximizes efficiency in moderate climates.
Hayward Universal H-Series 250,000 BTU Natural Gas Heater
The Hayward Universal H-Series is a high-output natural gas heater designed for in-ground pools and spas. With a 250,000 BTU capacity, it delivers fast temperature recovery and rapid heating for large water volumes. Key construction highlights include a cupro-nickel heat exchanger for enhanced corrosion resistance and an industry-focused hydraulic design to reduce pump run time and energy usage.
Call 888-896-7031 for Free Local HVAC Quotes – Compare and Save Today!
Suitability: Ideal where instant or rapid heating is required and natural gas is available. Gas heaters provide predictable temperature rise regardless of ambient air temperature, making them effective in cold climates or for quick spa heating. Installation requires gas line connection, proper ventilation, and regular maintenance of combustion components.
VARMINPOOL 16000BTU Pool Heat Pump
The VARMINPOOL unit is a smart inverter heat pump rated at 16,000 BTU, targeted at above-ground pools around 5,400 gallons. It uses inverter technology for continuous, efficient operation and includes built-in WiFi with a Smart Life app for remote temperature control and scheduling. The heat exchanger is specified as titanium, which improves durability in treated pool water.
Suitability: Best for medium-sized above-ground pools where energy-efficient, steady heating is preferred. Inverter operation reduces start-stop cycles and can lower operational electricity consumption. Performance is ambient temperature dependent, and installation requires proper water flow and clearance for the outdoor unit.
ECO POOLTECH EU50 Electric Pool Heater
The ECO POOLTECH EU50 is a plug-in style electric pool heat pump offering around 16,000 BTU equivalent output and a reported COP up to 5.6. It’s designed for pools up to 5,000 gallons and emphasizes low-maintenance, ETL-certified safety with a GFCI leakage protection switch. The unit incorporates a built-in flow sensor and automatic control that coordinates with pump timing for hands-off operation.
Call 888-896-7031 for Free Local HVAC Quotes – Compare and Save Today!
Suitability: Practical for smaller residential pools or owners seeking a compact, energy-conscious heater without gas plumbing. The plug-and-play approach simplifies installation but still requires adequate outdoor clearance and proper pump flow. Efficiency claims depend on ambient conditions and measured COP performance under standard testing.
Goplus Solar Pool Heater
The Goplus Solar Pool Heater is a solar-powered coil panel designed to supplement pool heating. It uses a black coil and a transparent dome to enhance solar absorption and can raise water temperature by an estimated 5.4–7.2°F under optimal sunlight. The panel features foldable legs, rotatable hose connectors, and the ability to connect multiple units in series to increase heating capacity.
Suitability: Best as a supplemental, low-operational-cost option for owners seeking to extend swim season without fuel or electricity. Solar performance is highly dependent on sun exposure, panel orientation, seasonal sunlight, and local climate. Requires pairing with a pump capable of recommended flow rates for efficient heat transfer.
Buying Guide: How To Choose The Right Pool Heater
Choosing the right heater requires balancing pool size, climate, desired heat-up speed, operational cost, and installation constraints. Below are the main considerations and comparison perspectives.
Pool Size And Heat Load
- Small Pools (≤5,000 gallons): Electric plug-in heat pumps (like the EU50) and small inverter units perform efficiently and are easier to install.
- Medium Pools (5,000–9,000 gallons): Inverter heat pumps (e.g., Aquastrong, VARMINPOOL) provide efficient continuous heating with better COP values.
- Large Pools & Spas: High-BTU natural gas heaters (Hayward, Raypak) deliver fast temperature rise and are favored for rapid recovery and spa use.
Energy Source And Operating Cost
- Heat Pumps (Electric): Most energy-efficient in moderate climates; COP indicates how many BTUs per watt-hour are produced. Inverter models adjust output and reduce cycling.
- Natural Gas: Higher BTU output and faster heating but fuel cost and combustion maintenance apply. Effective in very cold climates or when quick heating is needed.
- Solar Panels: Minimal operating cost and simple setup; performance heavily weather-dependent and often best as supplemental heat.
Climate And Ambient Temperature
Heat pump performance declines as ambient air temperature drops, since they extract heat from outside air. Gas heaters are unaffected by cold air for heating capacity, making them preferable in colder regions or for spa heating. Solar options require strong sunlight and are less effective in cloudy or short-day seasons.
Installation And Space Requirements
- Gas Heaters: Require gas line hookup, proper ventilation, and local code compliance; professional installation is typically necessary.
- Electric Heat Pumps: Need outdoor clearance for airflow and adequate electrical capacity; inverter models may require dedicated circuits and professional setup.
- Solar Panels: Need rooftop or ground space with good sun exposure and plumbing to integrate with pump and filter flow.
Durability And Materials
Look for titanium or cupro-nickel heat exchangers if pool water chemistry may be variable or if you use salt systems. Corrosion-resistant components extend life in treated water.
Controls, Connectivity, And Automation
WiFi and app control (Aquastrong, VARMINPOOL) provide scheduling, remote monitoring, and energy tracking. Built-in flow sensors and timers (ECO POOLTECH) can simplify operation by syncing with pump schedules.
Tips for Getting the Best HVAC Prices
- Prioritize Quality Over Cost
The most critical factor in any HVAC project is the quality of the installation. Don’t compromise on contractor expertise just to save money. - Check for Rebates
Always research current rebates and incentives — they can significantly reduce your overall cost. - Compare Multiple Quotes
Request at least three estimates before making your choice. You can click here to get three free quotes from local professionals. These quotes include available rebates and tax credits and automatically exclude unqualified contractors. - Negotiate Smartly
Once you've chosen a contractor, use the proven strategies from our guide — How Homeowners Can Negotiate with HVAC Dealers — to get the best possible final price.
Efficiency Metrics And Certifications
- COP (Coefficient Of Performance): Higher COP means more efficient heat production for heat pumps.
- BTU Rating: Use BTU output to estimate heating speed relative to pool volume.
- Third-Party Certifications: ETL, UL, or other safety approvals indicate verified safety and electrical compliance.
Operational Considerations
- Pump Flow: Most heaters require a minimum flow rate. Check manufacturer specs to ensure compatibility with existing pool pump.
- Noise And Placement: Outdoor units produce operational sound. Consider distance from living spaces and neighbors.
- Maintenance: Gas heaters require combustion and venting checks; heat pumps need occasional coil cleaning; solar panels may need periodic hose and connector inspections.
Comparison Perspectives
- Cost-to-Operate: Heat pumps typically cost less per BTU than electric resistance but more than solar (which has near-zero ongoing cost). Gas costs vary with local fuel prices.
- Time-To-Heat: Gas heaters heat fastest; high-BTU gas units and large heat pumps recover temperature quicker. Solar is slowest and depends on sunlight.
- Environmental Impact: Electric heat pumps have lower onsite emissions; solar has the lowest operational emissions; gas combustion produces CO2.
Practical Tips Before Purchase
- Match heater BTU/COP ratings to pool volume and local climate.
- Verify electrical/gas supply capacity and permit requirements.
- Check warranty coverage and recommended maintenance intervals.
- Consider combining technologies (solar preheat + heat pump) to balance operating cost and heating speed.